Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Why did Germany and her Allies lose WWI?



From the start, Germany and it's allies were set to have a tragic end; unlike the British, they did not have a strong Government to make good decisions involving the military, economic or cultural aspects of their country that was represented in the war. Towards the end, Germany's army began to completely deteriorate while England, France,and the USA were still standing confidently as they worked together and had strong and well-trained armies and navies, enough money to supply the soldiers with weapons, and the trust of their nation's people. Countless mistakes were made by the Central powers to drive them out of the war with nothing gained but millions of their own men dead.Events like the Zimmerman Telegram, the Von Schlieffen Plan, and the Battle of Jutland all contributed to the downfall of Germany and her allies in WWI. The Central powers' main mistake throughout the war though, was their political factors which created many more problems in other aspects of their Nation and the war including military, economic, and cultural.

The Central Powers deeply lacked a good political system which was the root cause of their collapse in the war. Firstly, the Germans followed an Authoritarian Government which is run by a leader or leaders and is usually unelected by the people and so, they do not have a say in any of the decisions that were made for the Nation. This structure was very ineffective in Germany as all the decisions were made by the top authority and at that time was Wilhelm and General Ludendorff. Both were unwilling to give up their command which was wrong of them because they made all the decisions without considering the opinions of their people and, if their method failed, there was no other back-up plan. Secondly, Germany's Alliance System with Austria-Hungary, the Ottoman Empire, Bulgaria, and Italy was very weak due to the fact that they didn't work well together and they were not reliable. Italy, as Austria-Hungary and Germany had taken the offensive alliance, refused to go to war and never actually fought on the side of the Central Powers. Furthermore, towards the very end of the war, Austria-Hungary stopped protecting Germany and they were left alone surrounded by the Alliance side with no help. On the other hand, Britain, France, and the US had a very strong alliance system as they worked very well together since only one supreme commander, General Ferdinand Foch, controlled all the Allied armies. Lastly, the Zimmerman Telegram also affected Germany greatly in the war on their political side as they sent a telegram to Mexico asking them to go against the US so that it would distract the US from entering the war and joining the Allies side and they promised them that if they won, Mexico would receive all their land back. They did not accept though since they were busy fighting their own war (Civil war) and the US found out and were raged. This became one other reason that the US entered the war.

Due to the fact that Germany had a disorganized political system, its military side was badly affected too. Their only military strategy was high-risk attack where, any opportunity they found, they would use all their strength and do everything they could to advance on the enemy but if they did not succeed, their only plan was to wait for the next chance to charge whereas the British had a professional army that had strict instructions on how to take over and destroy their enemy. The British also had DORA (Defense Of the Realm Act) which was a series of laws that made sure the soldiers had everything they needed and were capable of fighting in the war. Moreover, the Von Schlieffen Plan was Germany's military tactic to get back the land of Alsace and Lorraine from France which also failed. They wanted to go through Belgium which was a neutral country to get into France while the rest of the soldiers surrounded Russia in the East. As the Germans attempted this though, the French counterattacked on the outskirts of Paris and meanwhile, it gave time for the Russians to spread and end the German offensive. This resulted in years of trench warfare. Likewise, the Battle of Jutland that was between the British Navy and the German fleet (31st May-1st June 1916) began because the British Navy controlled the Northern Sea with Dreadnoughts and would sink any German ship they found. This cut supplies of food to Germany and nitrates which were needed to make explosives for the army and fertilizer for the farmers. This deeply concerned the German people about the war and they began to wish for the fighting to end as they were being starved at home. The Germans found a chance for defeat when they sunk the Lusitania, the largest passenger vessel that was coming from the US to England; it was said that it was only carrying cargo but was actually filled with weapons. This event was one of the big reasons the US entered the World War as many Americans died on that boat and now, the German people had completely lost faith in their Government.

All of these military failures that Germany was experiencing began to worry the German people and they were starting to believe that it would be better to stop fighting in the war as the only things happening were countless of their men dying everyday and the money given by the people towards the war was going to waste since there were no successes. Germany did not have a tax system so all the money that was used for the war was given by Germany's nationalists and people who trusted their Government. But since they weren't getting anywhere in the war and the German army was deteriorating, the Government started running out of money to use for weaponry as the people lost confidence in them. Additionally, Germany became isolated as they were surrounded by the Allied armies and they had no choice but to fight by themselves without any help from their alliances.
* People in Germany were becoming worried because countless of German men were dying every day at war and people at home were shocked because they didn't realise and were not informed of the huge risks of participating in the war. This lead to an untrustworthy relationship between Germany and its people because they felt betrayed by their nation due to the fact that they were not familiarized with the tragedy of the war and did not have an accurate idea of what was happening. When they started being aware of the amount of casualties of their army that they believed was extremely strong, they no longer felt the need to encourage the continuation of the war as they were let down by their Government.

Culturally, Germany was doomed from the start as Propaganda affected the way German soldiers fought in the war and the amount they trusted their Nation. A big mistake that the Germans made with their propaganda was that they ridiculed the worth of the enemy and the soldiers trusted that everything they said was the truth but when they were sent to war, they were shocked as they had a very different impression to what they saw in front of them. They did not expect such harsh brutality and did not have time to prepare so they felt deceived by their Nation's propaganda. On the other hand, British propaganda was much more truthful to its people and warned them of the barbarians they were to be faced with. This adjusted the soldiers to know what to expect and fight with all their might and it strengthened their self-esteem. When they got to the battle-field, they weren't scared off by the enemy, knew exactly how to act, and actually increased their hatred towards the Central Powers.

Many people today are trying to figure out whether Germany could have defeated their original enemies if the US did not enter the war but in my opinion, Germany and its allies were not strong as an Alliance System or Government to begin with and did not have a strict enough structure or prepared enough army to defeat Britain and France. These two countries, even working without the US were extremely well-prepared and Germany did not stand a chance compared to them, with or without the US, however long their army stayed up. They were deteriorating fast and Germany didn't even have their people's trust towards the end so I think, if the US did not enter the war, yes Germany would be able to hold up their army longer but I don't think they would be able to defeat France and Britain. In the end, Germany would have the same outcome since they would just grow weaker and the German people would crave peace which would force them to surrender.

The First World War was huge in the sense that for the first time, so many countries were involved and had created so many problems together. The Central Alliance was weak from the start and did not have a proper structure so the war didn't really benefit them in any way. They didn't gain much more than what they started with and instead lost millions of men in a time line of four years. Many mistakes were made by the Government of Germany and if they had planned out exactly how they were going to get what they wanted from the very start and if they were more organized, they might of had better luck in the war. But because of the wrong government structure, the lack of German peoples' opinion taken into consideration, and all the events that occurred that proved Germany was not worthy enough to fight in the war, Germany and its alliance system slowly and painfully declined affecting the Nation militarily, economically, and culturally.



2 comments:

  1. Task:
    Add 3 specific supporting details to the 4th paragraph. What evidence do you have that people were becoming worried and unhappy in Germany?
    You may list these in bullet points at the end of the paragraph or write them in sentence, up to you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought this was an excellent essay untill you mentioned Italy- They were a part of the Allied Forces during WWI and fought against Autria- HUngary

    ReplyDelete